COTC Wins 2018 Best Fleets to Drive For Best Overall Fleet for Small Carrier

On March 26th, 2018 TCA and CarriersEdge unveiled the two overall winners for 2018 Best Fleets to Drive For naming Central Oregon Truck Company as the Best Overall for Small Carrier and Bison Transport as the Best Overall for Large Carrier.

COTC has been participating in the CarriersEdge Best Fleets to Drive For competition since 2013 when CEO, Rick Williams, learned about the program.  Mr. Williams, a former flatbed driver, believes in the value of listening to drivers when developing Company policy.  He is also not one to back down from a challenge.  Deciding to participate in a competition of for-hire trucking companies that raise the bar in driver programs was probably the easiest decision he has ever made as CEO.

Each year, a COTC driver nominates the Company as a best fleet to drive for.  Then Mr. Williams, and his team, complete the questionnaire that collects information about COTC programs and policies in areas such as driver compensation and benefits; performance and recognition; human resource support; and operational strategy to name a few.  The 2018 competition included 98 questions that took more than 40 hours to complete. The questionnaire is followed up with an interview conducted by CarriersEdge of COTC management; and a survey completed by COTC drivers.  More than 60% of COTC drivers completed the 2018 Best Fleets to Drive For survey.

The results of the drivers’ survey are aggregated by CarriersEdge and used by the COTC management team to drive policy change in the coming year based on the feedback received.  The value of the survey responses to Mr. Williams and COTC management cannot be overstated.

Mr. Williams was humbled and honored to receive the award.  He stated in his acceptance speech,

What TCA and CarriersEdge do to bring to the forefront what we should all be doing for our drivers is amazing. We need to continue to work really hard for our driving teams.  Without dedication towards improving our industry and improving our businesses for all employees we wouldn’t be here.

We look forward to the 2019 Best Fleets to Drive For competition and hope to make the Top 20 for the sixth consecutive year.  COTC will continue to look forward, not back, and be a leader of change in the industry.

Watch the video for Best Fleets to Drive to For announcement at the 2018 TCA Conference for the Best Workplace Experience in the Small Carrier Category on the Truckload Carrier Associations Facebook page.

Read more about the Best Fleets to Drive For contest that recognizes the best workplaces for North American truck drivers.

 

Central Oregon Truck and Bison Transport Win Best Fleets to Drive For

Central Oregon Truck Company and Bison Transport have been named the overall winners of the annual 2018 Best Fleets to Drive For contest, put on by the Truckload Carriers Association and its partner CarriersEdge.

Central Oregon Truck Company of Redmond, Ore., won in the small fleet category, sponsored by EpicVue, and Bison Transport of Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada, won in the large carrier category, sponsored by Northbridge Insurance.

“These two companies are shining examples of consistency and innovation in trucking,” said John Lyboldt, TCA’s president. “Congratulations to Central Oregon and Bison for continuing to go above and beyond to create exemplary workplaces for their drivers.”

Best Fleets to Drive For is an annual survey and contest that recognizes North American for-hire trucking companies providing the best workplace experiences for their drivers. To participate, fleets must be nominated by a company driver or independent contractor working with them. Nominees are evaluated across a broad range of categories reflecting current best practices in human resources. The 20 top finishers are identified as Best Fleets to Drive For and then divided in half according to size. The highest scoring fleet in each category is named the overall winner.

Central Oregon Truck Company is a fleet of 314 trucks, and this is their first time winning Best Overall Fleet. The company has developed some of the most innovative programs in the industry, including an RFID system in their trucks that triggers a custom welcome when drivers return to the yard, as well as a concierge service that takes care of much of the return-related admin work. Central Oregon also received top marks for their compensation programs and operational strategy.

Bison Transport has placed in the Top 20 for eight of the ten years since the Best Fleets program was initiated, including three consecutive years winning Best Overall Large Fleet. This year also marks Bison’s fourth total Best Overall Large Fleet title, the first fleet to reach this milestone.

With a 1,456-truck fleet the company continues to find new ways to improve its offerings for drivers. This year it received top scores for performance management programs, driver development and career path options, and work/life balance.

“Both fleets are taking different approaches but achieving comparable results,” said Jane Jazrawy, chief executive officer of CarriersEdge. “Both are also fleets that have been pushing the envelope for years, embracing technology to improve efficiency and constantly coming up with new ideas to enhance their drivers’ experiences.”

Higher driver compensation packages, quicker access to health insurance among trends among nation’s top fleets

Whether there is a driver shortage or not has become a hot discussion of late, but regardless of which side of the argument you fall on, most will agree that driver compensation is crucial to hanging on to the drivers you currently have.

With tight capacity, higher rates, and tax cuts, many fleets have been boosting pay rates. In fact, driver pay rates have been on the rise for several years now. According to Glassdoor, truck drivers in February made an average of $53,932 per year, a 4.4% year-over-year increase.

While pay has been inching up, something else has been increasing, according to Mark Murrell, co-founder of CarriersEdge and creator of the Best Fleets to Drive For program: more fleets are offering guaranteed pay programs. Those programs may be minimum miles or pay, but both create a base pay level that drivers can expect.

Murrell said that in 2016, 17% of the fleets nominated for the Best Fleets to Drive For offered some sort of “full guarantee” for compensation, but in this year’s survey, 30% of fleets offer a full guarantee and another 43% offer a partial guarantee.

Murrell said that to his recollection, 4 years ago fewer than 5 fleets in the program offered guaranteed pay and because long-haul drivers are typically paid by the mile, it put pressure on drivers to cover as many miles as possible and penalized them in some case.

“It effectively is a base salary,” he told FreightWaves. “They’ll never make less than this … and it covers things out of a driver’s control, such as delays and equipment issues” that used to cut into pay.

Dispatchers and freight managers have often been cited by drivers as reasons for holding down pay because of inefficient routing and scheduling. “What it’s really doing is putting more pressure on the areas that should be having the pressure,” Murrell noted.

The latest data shows that the average median guaranteed pay is now $1,000 a week. “A very small percentage of drivers every week make this, the majority make more,” Murrell noted. “[But] it provides some breathing room.”

Murrell added that in 2016, the effective compensation rate for drivers in the fleet survey was 50.71 cents per mile. That increased last year to 54.32 cents per mile.

CashflowCornerBanner_640x100.jpg

Launched in 2008, the Best Fleets to Drive For program honors the top fleets in North America for drivers. A driver must nominate a fleet and once nominated, CarriersEdge researches the fleet. Murrell said 99 fleets were nominated this year with 58 fleets making the cut to advance. CarriersEdge surveys the fleets and digs into operations to cut the list to the final 20. Two overall winners will be announced at the Truckload Carriers Association conference later this month.

The surveys and information collected is used to generate detailed trends on a number of issues that matter to drivers, compensation is one of those. Murrell says a detailed data report will be released at TCA, but he shared some of the compensation information with FreightWaves ahead of the formal release.

In addition to salary information, CarriersEdge is focused on overall compensation packages, which include things like health care and profit-sharing programs. Murrell said this year’s survey didn’t show much change in the types of health coverage or premiums paid by fleets, but there has been a significant change, nonetheless.

“It used to be 3 months up to 6 months before people got insurance,” he said, “now we are seeing more drivers getting on [health plans] in 30 days. Fleets are seeing that if they can bring them on in 30 days…it makes it easier to attract more experienced, seasoned drivers.”

More fleets are also offering profit-sharing or 401K programs, Murrell said. In the survey, 13% of fleets now offer plans to drivers. Most of those plans are based on a percentage of revenue, but some offer stock option plans.

Murrell said that the surveys provide a great opportunity to collect data that CarriersEdge then offers back to the industry to help improve operations. The Best Fleets to Drive For contest is produced in partnership with TCA.

Here are the 2018 Top 20 Best Fleets to Drive For finalists:

  • American Central Transport, Inc., Kansas City, MO
  • Bison Transport, Winnipeg, MB
  • Boyle Transportation, Billerica, MA
  • Central Oregon Truck Company, Inc., Redmond, OR
  • Challenger Motor Freight, Inc., Cambridge, ON
  • Erb Group, New Hamburg, ON
  • Fremont Contract Carriers, Inc., Fremont, NE
  • FTC Transportation, Inc., Oklahoma City, OK
  • Garner Trucking, Inc., Findlay, OH
  • Grand Island Express, Inc., Grand Island, NE
  • Halvor Lines, Inc., Superior, WI
  • Maverick Transportation, LLC, North Little Rock, AR
  • Motor Carrier Service, LLC, Northwood, OH
  • Nussbaum Transportation, Hudson, IL
  • Prime Inc., Springfield, MO
  • Smokey Point Distributing, Arlington, WA
  • Thomas E. Keller Trucking, Defiance, OH
  • TLD Logistics Services, Inc., Knoxville, TN
  • TransPro Freight Systems, Ltd., Milton, ON
  • Veriha Trucking, Inc., Marinette, WI

Three companies, Bison Transport, Central Oregon Truck Company, and TransPro Freight Systems, have achieved the milestone of five consecutive years on the Best Fleets list.

The highest scoring fleets will be split into small and large fleet categories, from which two overall winners will be selected. The awards are sponsored by EpicVue of Salt Lake City, UT, and Northbridge Insurance of Toronto, ON.

Stable, Reliable Truck Driving Career

In 1992, Rick Williams shifted gears in his transportation career from being a truck driver to an owner of Central Oregon Truck Co., which he launched with a few business partners.

CEO of Central Oregon Truck Co.

Rick Williams, COTC’s CEO, says his experience as a truck driver formed his understanding of the value that high-quality drivers add to a trucking company.

Before purchasing fleet assets, COTC started out brokering local and regional freight in the Pacific Northwest. Today, the Redmond, Ore.-based flatbed carrier operates more than 300 trucks.

Williams says his experience as a truck driver formed his understanding of the value that high-quality drivers add to a trucking company. He wants COTC to be a place where top-level professional drivers choose to spend an entire career.

“There are multiple things we do that are high priorities on a driver’s list,” says Williams, the company’s chief executive officer. “We try to make sure that when we get a high-quality driver that this has become their new home.”

COTC has been recognized as a Best Fleet to Drive For by the Truckload Carriers Association for five consecutive years. Each year, program finalists are chosen by CarriersEdge – an online training provider that administers the program for TCA – via interviews with management and driver feedback.

Among the attributes that distinguish COTC’s workplace for drivers are generous pay, incentives and benefit programs. The company also has created unique systems to eliminate week-to-week pay variability and establish a personalized work experience.

Stabilizing pay

To smooth pay variability from one week to the next, COTC pays drivers on all actual and approved dispatch miles, including empty miles. Its payroll is not tied inflexibly to cutoff dates for delivery status and paperwork on loads.

Row of Semi-Trucks“We figured out how to handle that differently,” Williams says. “Our driving team members’ pay is very consistent.”

COTC also has a minimum pay guarantee program. To qualify, drivers must meet the fleet’s safety requirements and be willing and available to work 25 days out of the month.

The company’s minimum pay program makes up the difference between a driver’s gross monthly pay and a guaranteed monthly amount of $4,250, although drivers generally earn more than that. COTC’s pay program can be viewed as a “salary plus” program, Williams says.

The salary is based on the minimum guaranteed pay of $51,000 annualized, with performance pay that adds to it. The performance pay gives drivers of all experience levels an equal opportunity to increase their earnings. The program rewards up to an additional 12 cents per mile each month.

If a driver runs 12,500 miles in a month and qualifies for the full 12-cent performance pay, the driver would receive an additional $1,500. The percentage of drivers earning at least some of the performance pay is 98 percent, Williams says.

The program has measurements in four categories: performance, safety, fuel and “focused pay.” The data for each of these measurements come from systems that include telematics and video event recorders with inward- and outward-facing cameras.

The “focused pay” category is selected monthly based on COTC’s goals. The options are safety, productivity or a “new category,” Williams says. In February, the chosen category for focused pay was safety.

COTC 18-Wheeler

Drivers for COTC can schedule home time by using the company’s mobile app.

Last year, the company’s average annual wage was $57,000 before the paid benefits. Adding in this benefit, its average driver pay was $63,500. So far in 2018, the average driver pay is trending at $62,150, and with the performance incentives, some drivers will crest $80,000.

COTC also developed a mobile app for drivers to track their performance in each category to predict their monthly payout.

A vacation pay program also begins on day one with an accrual rate of between 1 to 3 cents per mile depending on experience, and drivers can use the pay accruals for more than taking days off. The company also offers paid sick days.

“We know things happen in life and that a lot of Americans live paycheck to paycheck,” Williams says. “The account becomes a slush fund that drivers can withdraw monies from, just like a savings account.”

Expanding benefits

Driver benefit programs are paid 100 percent by COTC for life, health, vision, dental and short-term disability insurance. Beyond the insurance benefits, the company also has a tax-savings program built into the pay package.

COTC TruckThe tax program consists of a safe harbor 401(k) plan with matching contributions and no vesting period, flexible healthcare spending accounts and per-diem pay that disperses weekly.

The safe harbor 401(k) and health insurance are among benefits that COTC shares with other flatbed carriers in the Daseke family of companies. COTC was acquired by Addison, Texas-based Daseke (CCJ Top 250, No. 37) in 2013.

“If drivers use all the benefits, the tax plan is very good,” Williams says. “Those kinds of things help drivers increase their net income with pretax dollars.”

COTC’s per-diem pay will remain in place after recent changes in the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act signed into law last year by President Trump. Companies that have a per-diem pay plan such as COTC’s can deduct between $17,000 and $20,000 of income annually for every driver. At COTC, this payroll deduction can save drivers between $3,000 and $4,000 in taxes annually.

Finding the right fit

While high pay and benefits certainly grab drivers’ attention, COTC’s core strategy for recruiting is to screen drivers to ensure the company is a good fit for the individual, Williams says.

COTC does not use “recruiter” in any job title. The company employs “hiring coordinators” who ensure that job applicants meet its qualifications and standards to ensure a fit. The fit also is based on the driver’s willingness to work and share core values and beliefs in safety.

“We don’t talk to (drivers) about pay before we discuss fit,” he says. “We are a process-driven company. We look at every one of our trucks as an individual franchise. We know how they make money, and if drivers follow the direction of the franchise, they will be successful.”

Individual attention

As the company has grown, Williams has placed an emphasis on developing technology to keep a personal touch with drivers. Despite operating more than 300 trucks, “we know all our drivers’ names,” he says.

The name recognition is nurtured by a policy that office and shop employees follow for using the driver’s name whenever they communicate information. When sending an email to the shop, an office employee would not write “Truck 863 is here for service,” but rather “Bill in truck 863 is here for service.”

CCJ Innovator: Load One app helps drivers optimize planning decisions

Expedite hauler Load One developed a mapping tool that provides drivers with historical and real-time data on demand and capacity.

To help create a personalized experience for drivers, COTC has radio frequency identification tags on all its trucks. As drivers enter the fleet’s yard, an RFID reader triggers the information that appears on a large screen. The driver is greeted by name and given relevant information about past loads and safety and recognized for recent accomplishments.

Similarly, screens pop up on office monitors to let staff know which drivers are entering the facility to “make sure we put a name with a face,” Williams says. Each department sees different information to facilitate work for the driver – such as vehicle maintenance or training meetings – while he and his equipment are at the yard.

All these efforts contribute to COTC’s driver satisfaction and retention. The company’s annualized driver turnover rate is 85 percent, but that includes drivers who do not pass orientation or drug tests, as well as those who retire or leave the industry, Williams says.

Once drivers understand COTC’s benefits and culture, turnover drops significantly, he says. Turnover for drivers with the company from one to three years is 70 percent; three to five years, 31 percent; and five or more years, 18 percent.

Excluding terminations and retirees from the three-to-five-year and five-year-plus groups, the turnover rate is 22 percent and 8 percent, respectively.

Compared to industry trends, “that is pretty low for a true long-haul irregular-route company,” Williams says.

Central Oregon Truck Named to the Top 20 Best Fleets to Drive For Five Consecutive Years

Twenty fleets have been recognized by the Truckload Carriers Association and CarriersEdge in the 2018 Best Fleets to Drive For program.

The carriers in the program must have at least 10 trucks and be nominated by a company driver or owner-operator. TCA says the fleets are being recognized “for providing exemplary work environments for their professional truck drivers and independent contractors.”

Following the nomination process, CarriersEdge interviewed human resources representatives and executives from the companies, then graded the fleets in a variety of categories, including compensation, benefits, professional development opportunities and more. Driver feedback was also incorporated into the final score.

Three companies on the list – Bison Transport, Central Oregon Truck Company and TransPro Freight Systems, have been on the list for five consecutive years.

At TCA’s Annual Convention in Kissimmee, Fla., on March 25-28, two overall winners from the list below will be named “Best Fleets to Drive For” for small fleet and large fleet categories. Last year, Grand Island Express and Bison Transport won the award in the small fleet and large fleet categories, respectively.

This year’s 20 Best Fleets to Drive For are:

  • American Central Transport – Kansas City, Mo. (No. 249 on the CCJ Top 250)
  • Bison Transport (No. 66) – Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada
  • Boyle Transportation – Billerica, Mass.
  • Central Oregon Truck Company – Redmond, Ore.
  • Challenger Motor Freight – Cambridge, Ontario, Canada (No. 77)
  • Erb Group – New Hamburg, Ontario, Canada
  • Fremont Contract Carriers – Fremont, Neb. (No. 230)
  • FTC Transportation – Oklahoma City, Okla.
  • Garner Trucking – Findlay, Ohio
  • Grand Island Express – Grand Island, Neb.
  • Halvor Lines – Superior, Wis. (No. 225)
  • Keller Logistics Group – Defiance, Ohio
  • Maverick Transportation – North Little Rock, Ark. (No. 74)
  • Motor Carrier Service – Northwood, Ohio
  • Nussbaum Transportation – Hudson, Ill.
  • Prime Inc. – Springfield, Mo. (No. 15)
  • Smokey Point Distributing – Arlington, Wash.
  • TLD Logistics Services – Knoxville, Tenn. (No. 218)
  • TransPro Freight Systems – Milton, Ontario, Canada
  • Veriha Trucking – Marinette, Wis.

Five fleets have also been identified as “Fleets to Watch” – honorable mentions for their innovative driver programs, TCA says:

  • Bennett Motor Express – McDonough, Ga. (No. 59)
  • Hoekstra Transportation – Grand Rapids, Mich.
  • Larway Transportation – Barrie, Ontario, Canada
  • LoadOne – Taylor, Mich.
  • Werner Enterprises – Omaha, Neb. (No. 11)

Truck Driver Per Diem Don’t Lose It

President Trump signed the biggest overhaul to the United States tax code in more than 30 years.

The tax over haul will affect all American’s.  Especially, the over the road truck driver.  The good news is that the standard deduction has roughly doubled for all filers.  The bad news is drivers that previously relied on the per diem tax deduction as a form of savings have lost their savings plan.

That is due to the elimination of the unreimbursed employee expense deduction.  The per diem deduction was classified as an unreimbursed employee expense deduction.

Central Oregon Truck Company offers all drivers per diem pay.  Per diem pay is not in addition to your weekly wages. It is a change in classification of wages earned to, reimbursed employee expense, eliminating the tax consequence associated with wages. Federal Income Tax, State Income Tax, Social Security Tax and Medicare Tax are not taken out of reimbursed business expenses, but are taken out of wages.  Participating in a per diem program should significantly increase net take-home pay.

Most trucking companies provide company truck drivers a per diem program.  However, many of them charge a fee for the program then force enrollment.

It Is Your Money. You Earned It. You Should Get to Keep All of It!

The fee reduces your take-home pay and increases the profitability of the trucking company by decreasing driver wage expense on the income statement.  Drive for a company that doesn’t take your hard earned money, and call it a fee.

COTC Does NOT Charge a Fee for Per Diem

Under the old mileage plan $0.12 cents of base cents per mile was paid as a reimbursed employee expense for per diem.  Following the change to Weekly Truck Driver Salary Pay per diem will be paid at a flat $68 per day for 5 nights out each week.

COTC Partners with Washington Federal

Financial wealth includes access to the maximum credit at the lowest interest rates.  Making the most money possible paid on steady, reliable weekly paychecks is essential to building wealth.

As a truck driver in America you should not be held back from buying the home your family needs because you are enrolled in a truck driver per diem plan.  Truck driver per diem plans allow up to $68 dollars a day in per diem for each night away from home.  Truck drivers are lucky in that they are included in the IRS definition of transportation worker per diem, IRS Revenue Procedure 2011-47, whereby your per diem is considered wages; but taxed as an expense reimbursement.  Meaning, it counts as earnings and should increase your available credit, while also increasing your net take home. Per diem it is not taxable for Federal and State Income Taxes.  One of those rare examples where the truck driver comes out ahead!

Paul Coil, the Chief Financial Officer of Central Oregon Truck Company, met with the executive team of Washington Federal Bank to partner with them on half of COTC drivers regarding the US Tax Code as it relates to per diem and driver compensation.  Mr. Coil states,

One of the often cited issues drivers have had with participating in the per diem plan is that the compensation you receive as per diem is omitted from Boxes 1, 3, & 5 of your W-2, therefore most banks won’t recognize the per diem as legitimate on-going compensation. This is directly related to an FHA guideline that stipulates that mortgages to be sold in the secondary market seeking FHA protection can only rely on income that shows up in these boxes on the W-2.

There are, however, lenders like Washington Federal that are “portfolio lenders”, which means they keep all their loans on their books, so these FHA guidelines don’t apply to them.  Having provided the leadership at Washington Federal with the specifics of the tax code as it relates to drivers, they are now convinced of the legitimacy of our drivers’ per diem as an on-going, reliable compensation for consideration when making home loan decisions.

Learn More about how Washington Federal supports COTC drivers and take advantage of another one of the many benefits of employment at COTC.  We also have a Washington Federal customer service representative standing by at the Redmond, Oregon branch to answer any questions.  If you do not reside in a state with a Washington Federal branch location and are thinking about a home purchase Mr. Coil recommends lenders that are “portfolio lenders” who have much greater flexibility in considering per diem compensation.

Understanding truck driver per diem is even more important with the changes to the tax code for 2018.  You do not have to lose the tax benefits of per diem Read More.